Any Physician named as a Defendant in a malpractice lawsuit can tell you there is a world of difference between the “what if” world of asset planning and the “what now” world of real litigation. While the vast majority of lawsuits are settled before trial and within policy limits, the resolution of one bad experience is no guarantee that another bad experience won’t follow it in the future.
At least some of the stress and concerns about financial security can be relieved by reviewing what asset protection is available and avoiding certain common mistakes.
ASSETS HELD IN MARITIAL JOINT NAMES (Tenancies by the Entirety):
Simply putting of the husband’s and wife’s name on the same asset title does not automatically protect that asset from the creditors of one spouse. The marital status of the owners must be clearly identified on the Deed for account title (e.g. Harry Jones and Sandy Jones his wife or Harry Jones and Sandy Jones Tenants by the Entirety). Common mistakes in this area include certificates of investments in privately held companies entitled to out of state real estate. The mare fact that the owners listed on the title are married does not automatically create marital protection.
Another common mistake occurs after one spouse is faced with an actual lawsuit for potential claim that could exceed insurance coverage. At that point, the spouse “at risk” should ask the questions “what happens to the joint marital property if my spouse dies before or after this lawsuit is over?” The answer in all cases is that the joint marital property loses its’ protection and can then be attached by a judgment creditor. In the face of a real threat, joint marital ownership is no guarantee of asset protection other steps (e.g. spendthrift Trust) must be taken.
HOMESTEAD PROPERTY:
The Florida Constitution provides absolute and unlimited protection against attachment of a “Florida homestead” whether owned in joint marital names or in a singe name. However, this asset protection extents only to one half acre inside a municipality and 160 acres outside the municipality. The lots and many upscale residential areas exceed one half acre and are not protected by the Florida Constitution.
RETIREMENT PLANS AND INDIVIDUAL RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS:
Besides being a good financial and tax planning option, qualified retirement plans and individual retirement accounts are fully exempt from creditors under both state and federal law. The key word in the last sentence is “qualified”. While the IRS may allow you to correct discrepancies in coverage, contribution and permitted investments, a creditor may be able to seize Plan assets due to these technical defects. If asset protection is a concern, use of experienced third party plan administers is a must.
BENEFICIARY DESIGNATIONS AND INHERITANCES:
One of the most common mistakes occurs when an otherwise fully protected position unexpectedly receives life insurance proceeds, retirement plan benefits or an inheritance. While such assets may have been fully protected on the previous name of a spouse or other family member, that protection is lost the minute it is received by the beneficiary or heir. Asset Protection Trust should be used in the case of life insurance, annuities, or retirement plan assets payable to a Physician as beneficiary. In the case of a future inheritance a candid discussion with other family members may be necessary, no matter how difficult.
PRACTICE ASSETS:
A common concern and common mistake is the protection of accounts receivable. Leveraged life insurance “protection” programs are often promoted as a means for both large and small medical groups to shield their accounts receivable. In my opinion, these programs costs too much, provide uncertain protection and may result in IRS tax issues. Simpler and cheaper solutions include: (i) Pledging the accounts receivable toward a revolving line of credit to be used if and when necessary; (ii) Pledging the accounts receivable as additional security toward medical office lease payments (if the medical office is owned by related parties).
MALPRATICE AND OTHER LIABILITY INSURANCE COVERAGE:
The debate will never end whether minimum coverage is enough or extra coverage makes the Physician a “target”. Experienced Plaintiff and Defense attorneys alike can attach a “price” on almost any malpractice lawsuit once the full extent of permanent injury is ascertained. While many “worst case” injuries are still within minimum policy limits, certain procedures on certain patients can have catastrophic results. In my opinion, Physicians who perform high risk-high injury procedures should increase their coverage. The stress and worry of defending the claim for two or three times insurance coverage is a great deal worst that the extra premium expense.
Whether minimum or greater malpractice insurance is purchased, be certain the insurance company is solvent and determine if defense costs are “included” or in addition to the stated coverage amount. The legal fees and expert witness expense to fully defend a lawsuit through the stage of a jury trial can be expected to exceed $75,000.
In the case of other types of lawsuits (e.g., automobile negligence, teenage drivers and parties without adult supervision), every parent and every person with assets worth protecting should have “umbrella” liability insurance of at least $3 million (preferably $5 million).
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES (LLC) AND OTHER GROUP ENTITIES:
LLC’s have become the entity of choice for group ownership of medical offices and substantial practice assets. Because the creditor of an individual member is only to entitled to a “charging order”, a member’s interest cannot be directly attached and the creditor cannot interfere with the operation of the LLC. However, the day will eventually come when the other members of the LLC will want to refinance, sell or otherwise make distributions as a return on their investments. At the time of such distributions, the charging order creditor can attach a member’s share and the asset protection of the LLC is lost.
In the case of a group medical practice, many LLC Operating Agreements are written to allow Physician Ownership only and to provide for forced sale in the event of a member’s bankruptcy or other financial trouble. In the case of all such group investments, the following questions should be asked and answered:
1. Can ownership be held by another protected entity (e.g., spouse or another LLC)?
2. Is the purchase of a distressed member’s interest mandatory or discretionary?
3. Is each member fully liable (jointly and severally) for the debts of the LLC or just their proportion and share?
TRENDS AND TRIBULATIONS:
While the states of Alaska and Nevada has been promoting themselves as asset protection havens, they have yet to be any federal court decisions on the effectiveness of this strategy. For those Physicians facing “last resort” asset protection planning, several offshore jurisdictions still offer the best “and most expensive” options.
As a result of one single Bankruptcy Court decision in Colorado, many advisors have become skeptical of singe member LLC’s. Because Florida law expressly limits creditors of a LLC member to charging order protection only, single member LLC’s remain a valid asset protection option in Florida. Where appropriate, additional LLC members (e.g., other family members eliminate this Bankruptcy Court issue altogether.
Given the recent opportunity to either expand or restrict various asset protections statutes, the Florida Legislature has favored increasing rather than reducing asset protection options.
No comments:
Post a Comment