Silver Lining

Silver Lining

Yes, your business is down. Yes, we may (or may not) be slowly coming out of the recession but the economic climate will not be the same as it was a few years ago. Yes, the value of your business is at its lowest point since you began the business in 1984.

Even in the darkest of times, I always try to find a silver lining. So here it is: this is the perfect time to explore gifting shares of the business to younger family members.

Let’s look at an example: Mr. Gates owns a tech business called Computers R Us, LLC (as you saw in previous article, there are advantages to owning small business as LLC rather than corporation). Mr. Gates owns 80% of Computers R Us, LLC, while his son owns 10% and his daughter owns 10%. In 2007, the business was valued at $3,500,000. It is now worth $2,500,000. Mr. Gates has a meeting with his attorney and realizes that if the Unified Credit drops to $1,000,000 as it is set to do in 2011, significant estate tax will be owed on the value of his business alone at his death. After exploring several tax strategies and planning tools, Mr. Gates decides to transfer 20% of his interest to each of his children. Now, Mr. Gates owns 40% and each of his children own 30%. So what has Mr. Gates achieved?

First, the Internal Revenue Code allows an annual gift of $13,000 to be excluded from tax. Mr. Gates is married so between the two of them, they can pass $26,000 under the annual exclusion. The above-described transfer of business interest is eligible for this gift exclusion. Currently, the marginal estate tax rate is 45%. Therefore, Mr. Gates provided savings to his family of $23,400 ($26,000 x 45% x two children).

Second, the value of the interest transferred to each child is $500,000. If the value of the business returns to 2007 levels, the value of those interests will be $700,000. Yet, Mr. Gates transferred $400,000 free from estate or gift tax because the value of the transfer is frozen at the $500,000 level (value at the time of the gift). Thus Mr. Gates provided additional savings to his family of $180,000 ($200,000 x 45% x two children).

Third, the Internal Revenue Code allows certain valuation discounts due to minority interests and lack of marketability. Often times, these discounts can be 25% or more. Due to the fact that the transfers to the children were minority interests and lacked marketability (unlike shares of stock traded on the Stock Exchange, there is no readily available market to buy interest in Computers R Us, LLC), such gifts may be discounted by 25%. As a result, the gift of $500,000 may be discounted by $125,000 resulting in Mr. Gates’ family saving $112,500 ($125,000 x 45% x two children).

Lastly, at Mr. Gates death, his estate can claim a minority interest and lack of marketability discounts against any remaining interests. Thus, Mr. Gates passes away in 2012 when the value of Computers R Us, LLC is $5,000,000. His estate may be able to claim a minority interest and lack of marketability discounts since Mr. Gates owns 40% of the company at his passing. So Mr. Gates has saved his family an additional $675,000. (45% x ($2,000,000 – $500,000).

So, yes, the economy is terrible. Yes, the value of the company is less than what it used to be. But through proper planning, Mr. Gates saved his family over $990,000 in estate taxes. See, I can always find a silver lining.

WORD OF CAUTION: Currently, there is proposed legislation threatening the viability of lack of marketability and minority interest discounts. With the White House spending into historic deficits, money will need to be raised through taxes. Therefore, please consult with a qualified attorney so that proper planning may be done specific to your factual situation and current laws.